Why you need an independent health insurance broker if you use Gusto

Feb 3, 2025 | Uncategorized | 0 comments

Using Gusto for health insurance? You might be missing out. While Gusto is great for payroll and basic benefits, its health insurance options are limited to six carriers and lack personalized support. Independent brokers, on the other hand, offer access to more carriers, tailored advice, and compliance expertise – especially crucial in states like Illinois with complex regulations like HB 2296. Here’s why an independent broker is essential:

  • More Plan Options: Brokers provide access to all available carriers, unlike Gusto’s six.
  • Personalized Support: Brokers help with claims, compliance, and employee assistance.
  • Cost Savings: Strategies like ICHRA/QSEHRA can save 15-25% annually.
  • State Expertise: Brokers ensure compliance with laws like Illinois’s premium oversight rules.

Quick Comparison:

FeatureGustoIndependent Broker
Plan Options6 carriersFull market access
Compliance SupportBasic ACA toolsComprehensive state/federal
Employee AssistanceSelf-service portalDirect, personal help
Cost ManagementLimited toolsAdvanced strategies

Independent brokers complement Gusto’s platform with expertise, cost control, and hands-on support, making them a smart choice for businesses navigating health insurance complexities.

What Gusto Can’t Do for Health Insurance

Gusto

Gusto’s Basic Health Insurance Features

Gusto integrates health insurance with payroll, offering small-group plans from six carriers. It handles straightforward tasks like enrollment and premium payments, making it a convenient choice for basic benefits administration [1].

Limited Support and Plan Options

While Gusto covers the basics, it doesn’t provide the in-depth support that many businesses need. Here’s where it falls short:

Service NeedGusto’s LimitationWhat a Broker Provides
Plan AccessLimited to 6 carriersAccess to all available carriers in the market
Strategic GuidanceGeneralized recommendationsTailored solutions based on workforce needs
Regulatory ComplianceBasic ACA reportingFull compliance support and monitoring
Employee AssistanceSelf-service portal onlyDirect, personal help with claims and questions

Another drawback is Gusto’s lack of support for specialized benefits like QSEHRA (Qualified Small Employer HRA) and ICHRA (Individual Coverage HRA), which are no longer available through the platform [2].

Cost Management Challenges

When it comes to managing costs, Gusto’s platform lacks the advanced tools and expertise that independent brokers can offer. For example, brokers like Illinois Health Agents provide services such as employer contribution strategies and tax-saving solutions for businesses with more than 10 employees – often at no extra cost.

Some of Gusto’s cost management limitations include:

  • No ability to negotiate better rates or adjust employer contributions effectively
  • Absence of long-term strategies to control costs
  • Lack of state-specific expertise for cost-saving measures

In states like Illinois, where legislation such as HB 2296 has introduced new rate review requirements, these gaps can create significant challenges. Businesses navigating complex health insurance laws and regulations often need expert advice to avoid unnecessary expenses [3].

Illinois Health Insurance Rules and Requirements

Illinois Insurance Laws

Employers in Illinois must follow the Affordable Care Act (ACA) guidelines, which include offering affordable health coverage to at least 95% of full-time employees and their children up to age 26. Additionally, House Bill 2296 has introduced stricter oversight measures. These include requiring insurance carriers to justify their rates, submit detailed transparency reports, and comply with consumer protection rules.

RequirementImpact on Businesses
Rate JustificationHelps ensure fair pricing of premiums
Premium ReviewAllows the DOI to reject unreasonable rates
Transparency ReportsPromotes accountability among carriers
Consumer ProtectionShields consumers from unfair rate increases

Broker Knowledge of State Rules

Independent brokers stay updated on Illinois insurance regulations through ongoing education and direct communication with regulatory agencies. This deep understanding helps businesses remain compliant while also improving their health insurance strategies in ways that platforms like Gusto cannot match. This expertise will be even more critical as Illinois transitions to a state-run health insurance marketplace by 2026 under House Bill 579.

"HB2296 significantly advances health care affordability." [3]

Meeting State Requirements

Businesses face specific compliance challenges that may not be fully addressed by platforms like Gusto. Failing to meet ACA requirements can lead to hefty financial penalties. Brokers play a key role in helping businesses navigate these challenges:

Compliance AreaBroker SupportGusto Platform
Rate Review & State UpdatesOffers real-time guidance and helps meet DOI requirementsLimited carrier options and general updates
ACA ReportingProvides full compliance monitoringBasic reporting tools only
DocumentationPrepares custom compliance paperworkOffers standard forms only

As Illinois adopts stricter premium oversight – joining 41 other states – independent brokers become an essential resource. While Gusto provides a solid starting point for benefits administration, brokers deliver tailored solutions and additional services that help businesses succeed in Illinois’s regulated insurance environment.

Services Beyond Gusto’s Platform

Gusto provides a starting point for benefits administration, but independent brokers bring a much broader range of services to the table.

Company and Employee Need Assessment

Independent brokers take a deep dive into your business, analyzing elements like employee demographics, industry-specific risks, and claims data. This helps identify coverage gaps and craft insurance plans that fit your unique needs.

Assessment AreaBroker AnalysisImpact on Coverage
Employee Needs and UsageDemographics, health needs, claims dataTailored plan options
Industry Risk FactorsOccupational hazards, workplace concernsBroader coverage considerations

This level of analysis ensures businesses have access to a wide variety of plans and carriers, offering solutions that align with their specific requirements.

Access to More Carriers and Plans

Gusto connects users to six insurance carriers. Independent brokers, on the other hand, tap into a much larger network of providers. This expanded access is especially important as Illinois prepares to transition to a state-run marketplace in 2026. Brokers can secure specialized plans like level-funded health plans, industry-focused group plans, and hybrid options – choices that platforms like Gusto simply can’t match.

After selecting the right plans, brokers also help businesses manage costs with flexible payment strategies.

Custom Payment Plans

Independent brokers create payment strategies that balance employer budgets with employee preferences. Here’s how they do it:

Contribution StrategyBusiness BenefitEmployee Impact
Tiered Premium SupportKeeps budgets under controlOffers employees coverage options
HSA IntegrationProvides tax advantagesEnables pre-tax healthcare savings

Brokers ensure compliance with the 50% minimum contribution rule and uncover tax-saving opportunities [5]. Their expertise allows them to design plans that meet the needs of diverse workforces while adhering to both Illinois regulations and ACA requirements.

sbb-itb-a729c26

Ways to Save Money

Gusto offers basic tools for managing costs, but brokers take it a step further by providing strategies to cut expenses while maintaining quality coverage. Their expertise ensures businesses get the most value without sacrificing protection.

Getting Better Insurance Rates

Brokers use their industry connections and market insights to secure lower premium rates. By analyzing your business profile and claims history, they negotiate better terms and suggest cost-efficient options like ICHRA or QSEHRA, which can cut costs by 15-25% annually while tailoring the plan to your needs [1].

Cost-Saving StrategyPotential Savings
ICHRA/QSEHRA15-25% annually
High Deductible Plan + HSAUp to 40% on premiums
Partially Self-Funded Plans10-30% for healthy groups

Funding and Tax Strategies

Brokers identify funding structures that work best for your business while helping you take advantage of tax benefits. Some effective methods include:

  • Partially self-funded plans, which may refund premiums if claims are lower than expected.
  • HSA-compatible plans, allowing employees to save pre-tax dollars for medical expenses.
  • Premium Saver programs, which pair high-deductible plans with reduced out-of-pocket maximums to lower premiums.

Tax benefits you might qualify for include:

  • The Small Business Health Care Tax Credit, covering up to 50% of premium contributions for eligible employers [2].
  • Tax-free premium reimbursements through properly designed HRA programs.
  • State-specific tax benefits, especially relevant for businesses in Illinois.

Brokers stay informed about Illinois regulations, ensuring your health benefits align with both state and federal tax laws. They also provide ongoing support to keep your insurance program running smoothly throughout the year.

Direct Support Services

While Gusto manages benefits administration, independent health insurance brokers provide the kind of personalized, hands-on support that technology platforms simply can’t match. Their tailored approach ensures businesses get the right coverage and consistent help throughout the year.

Help with Claims and Issues

Brokers are your go-to partners for resolving claim disputes, fixing billing errors, and negotiating with carriers. They work quickly – often resolving claims within 24-48 hours – and respond promptly to coverage questions, sometimes even the same day.

Annual Plan Reviews

Each year, brokers review your plans to ensure they meet your company’s changing needs. They look for ways to save money, improve coverage, and stay compliant with updated regulations. By analyzing claims data and gathering employee feedback, brokers help businesses adapt to Illinois’s shifting insurance landscape.

Employee Support and Training

Brokers provide one-on-one help during enrollment periods, offering clear resources to guide employees in making informed decisions. They also handle life event changes and new hire enrollments, ensuring every employee receives the support they need.

"Having state-based support ultimately makes it easier for Illinois consumers to shop for insurance" [3]

For companies with remote teams or multiple locations, brokers maintain open communication channels year-round. They address employee concerns quickly, ensuring businesses and their teams have the tools and guidance to navigate health insurance challenges without unnecessary stress.

Conclusion

Teaming up with an independent health insurance broker offers businesses using Gusto’s platform a well-rounded solution that goes beyond what technology alone can provide. This collaboration addresses challenges in compliance, cost management, and employee support.

Brokers like Illinois Health Agents offer tailored guidance to help businesses navigate the intricate Illinois regulations, ensuring both compliance and cost savings. This approach equips businesses to handle the complexities of the state’s healthcare system with confidence.

Financially, businesses gain an edge through strategic plan selection. For example, meeting the 50% premium contribution requirement for SHOP-qualified health plans can unlock tax benefits. By blending Gusto’s streamlined administrative tools with the expertise of independent brokers, businesses can develop a smooth and effective health insurance plan.

This partnership also brings a human touch that technology platforms lack. While Gusto manages the administrative side, brokers deliver strategic advice that enhances the platform’s functionality, resulting in a stronger benefits program.

In today’s challenging healthcare environment, working with an independent health insurance broker is more than just helpful – it’s a smart move. This combination allows businesses to stay focused on growth while keeping employee health coverage compliant and cost-efficient.

FAQs

What additional benefits does Gusto provide?

Gusto’s platform includes a range of additional benefits such as medical, dental, vision, life, and disability insurance. It also supports tax-advantaged accounts like HSAs, FSAs, DCFSAs, and commuter benefits. The platform makes it easy for employees to manage these benefits with online enrollment and administration tools.

"With Gusto, you get 100% online enrollment. Your employees can enroll in benefits, add dependents, and review their plan details in their Gusto account." – Gusto Benefits Team

Independent brokers can take these offerings a step further by:

  • Reviewing usage data to recommend cost-effective benefit options
  • Advising on the best benefits for your team’s needs
  • Ensuring compliance with Illinois state regulations
  • Highlighting ways to optimize tax savings
  • Providing ongoing help with claims and benefit usage

Gusto simplifies the logistics, while brokers bring the expertise to help your business make the most of these benefits [1][4].

Related Blog Posts

More News

0 Comments

Leave a Reply