Select Page
› ACA vs Short-Term Health Plans in Illinois: Short-Term Is Banned

Short-term health plans are banned in Illinois. Public Act 103-0649 took effect January 1, 2025, so no insurer can sell or renew one to an Illinois resident. The real choice now is between an ACA plan and an indemnity plan. Here is how they compare:

  • ACA plans: comprehensive coverage, pre-existing conditions covered, subsidies for those who qualify, and a yearly out-of-pocket maximum.
  • Indemnity plans: set cash benefits paid from the first dollar, a quick start and no end date, but not ACA coverage.
  • Short-term plans: no longer sold in Illinois.

Understanding ACA and Indemnity Plans

ACA Plans

ACA plans must cover essential health benefits and cannot turn you down or charge more because of a pre-existing condition. Premiums are based on age, location and tobacco use, and subsidies can lower them. Every plan has a yearly out-of-pocket maximum. You enroll during open enrollment or after a qualifying life event.

Indemnity Plans

Indemnity plans such as Allstate Health Access pay set cash amounts for services like office visits, emergency care, hospital stays and surgery, whatever the provider bills. There is no deductible, you can apply any time, coverage can start as early as the next day, and plans have no end date. They are not ACA coverage, they do not cover pre-existing conditions during the first 12 months, and you pay any bill above the set benefit.

Comparing Coverage

Feature ACA Plans Indemnity Plans Short-Term Plans
Sold in Illinois Yes Yes No, banned since Jan 1, 2025
Pre-existing conditions Covered Not covered the first 12 months Not covered
Deductible Usually yes None Usually yes
Out-of-pocket maximum Yes No; you pay above the benefit Varied
Subsidies Yes, if you qualify No No
Length One plan year, renewable No end date Temporary

Choosing Between ACA and Indemnity Plans

  • Choose an ACA plan if you have ongoing health needs, take regular prescriptions, or qualify for subsidies.
  • Choose an indemnity plan if you want cash from the first dollar, need coverage quickly between plans, or want extra cash on top of other coverage.
  • Use both if you want an ACA plan for comprehensive protection and cash benefits to cover deductibles and coinsurance.

FAQs

Can I still buy short-term health insurance in Illinois?

No. Illinois banned short-term, limited-duration plans effective January 1, 2025.

What replaces short-term health insurance?

Most people compare an ACA plan, COBRA if they are leaving a job, and indemnity plans that pay set cash benefits.

Do indemnity plans count as ACA coverage?

No. Indemnity plans are not ACA coverage and do not satisfy the coverage requirement, so many people pair them with an ACA plan.

Need help comparing? See your short-term alternatives, get a quote or call 312.726.6565.

Related Blog Posts